Psychedelic drugs to treat depression
Researchers are exploring the science of psychedelic drugs as a potential treatment for depression. How effective could they be, and what are the regulatory and legal challenges in their use?
How is PTSD treated, how successful are current treatments and what is the potential role for psychedelic-assisted therapy?
DOI: https://doi.org/10.58248/RR13
POST has published briefings focussed on the use of psychedelics to treat depressive disorders, anxiety disorders and eating disorders. This is part of our wider work on the use of psychedelics to treat mental health conditions. POST will publish a major briefing on the theme later in 2024. This briefing discusses post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and covers:
PTSD is a complex anxiety disorder caused after exposure to one or more traumatic events. This involves ingrained traumatic memories in the brain. In international medical diagnostic criteria the main symptoms are:
These symptoms persist for several weeks or longer and significantly impact various aspects of life, such as personal relationships, work and social activities.
PTSD is caused by myriad traumatic experiences. These can be single, repeated or multiple events, including but not limited to:
This means that, in evaluating the effectiveness of the treatments for PTSD, it is important to consider the nature and extent of symptoms, as well as the origin of the trauma.
Often, psychological interventions can be used shortly after traumatic experiences to try to prevent the onset of PTSD. Both medication and talking therapies can help to treat people who have already developed PTSD. Overall, such treatments are successful in about 35-40% of patients.
Pharmacological (drug) treatment is not currently recommended by NICE to prevent PTSD in individuals experiencing acute stress following a traumatic event/s. However, it has a role for individuals who have already developed PTSD and who may have a preference for drug treatment, or if other treatments have failed. These include:
All of the treatments above were considered ‘off-label’ as of 2018 when this guidance was last reviewed by NICE. This means the use of an approved drug for an unapproved indication or in an unapproved age group, dosage, or route of administration.
These include:
Research into the use of psychedelic-assisted psychotherapy for PTSD has been conducted using MDMA, ketamine, and the four ‘classical psychedelics’ (psilocybin, LSD, mescaline and DMT). These are described in POST’s rapid response article on depression.
Generally, this approach involves ‘non-trip’ sessions with a medical professional to ensure safety, prepare the patient and build a relationship, and a minimum of one ‘trip’ session where the patient undergoes a form of talking therapy after administration of a psychedelic compound.
Evidence from studies conducted in hundreds of participants suggests that psychedelic-assisted psychotherapy may be an effective treatment for PTSD. However, to date, there is not enough information from large clinical trials with sufficient participants comparing psychedelic-assisted psychotherapy directly to existing treatments.
MDMA is thought to increase social behaviour and emotional empathy, and subjective judgements of openness and trust. MDMA-assisted psychotherapy for PTSD was first studied in a clinical trial of six women with PTSD resulting from sexual assault. The number of participants was very small, but the study demonstrated the possible safety (both physically and mentally) of using such a treatment in this patient cohort. Since then, more robust trials have been published:
A 2019 ‘pooled analysis’ of these results combined the results of the above trials and others, for 72 participants receiving MDMA-assisted psychotherapy. After two sessions, more than double the number of patients in the group receiving MDMA-assisted psychotherapy no longer met the diagnostic criteria for PTSD than those receiving psychotherapy alone. This study outlined a possible protocol for a phase 3 clinical trial.
In 2023, results from a multi-site randomised, double-blinded phase 3 study for MDMA-assisted psychotherapy for PTSD were published. Of 104 participants, 53 received MDMA-assisted psychotherapy and 51 were given a placebo alongside therapy. At 18 weeks, the participants receiving the MDMA-assisted psychotherapy reported ongoing significantly improved PTSD symptoms and functioning compared with those receiving a placebo and therapy.
Ketamine is of increased interest to researchers since the early 2000s due to its antidepressant properties. POST has published evidence on its use in treatment-resistant depression. Ketamine is sometimes referred to as a ‘dissociative psychedelic’, which underpins the interest in its use as an adjunct to therapy, and as a treatment on its own. One form of ketamine, esketamine (as a nasal spray), is approved by the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) to treat depression.
In contrast to the other drugs included in this briefing, ketamine has been studied for its possible use as a treatment in isolation (without psychotherapy) in some research. Researchers believe this may be possible due to short-term changes to some connections in the brain:
Ketamine-assisted psychotherapy was used in a study combining an infusion of ketamine with a form of mindfulness-based cognitive therapy (MBCT) in 20 participants. This study reported comparatively longer duration of the improvement of symptoms in individuals given ketamine with MBCT than those receiving MBCT alone (34 days versus 11 days).
A comprehensive review article focussed on ketamine for PTSD was published in 2023. This review collated the results of several studies and reported a pooled analysis of the published data on ketamine. It found that overall there was evidence of reductions in PTSD symptoms with ketamine treatment, but significant variation between individual studies. This is likely due to the various outcome measures used by researchers to determine whether an intervention is beneficial, in addition to three papers using ketamine alone and only two using ketamine-assisted psychotherapy.
The research focussed on classical psychedelics to treat PTSD is comparatively limited.
Psilocybin-assisted group therapy was studied in 18 men who were long-term AIDS survivors. It found that symptoms in keeping with PTSD declined following treatment and was sustained at three months. However, this study predominantly focussed on ‘demoralisation’ among participants and only three of eighteen participants met PTSD diagnostic criteria.
Some other studies focussed on depression and anxiety as their primary outcomes have indicated a possible promise for the treatment of PTSD, but they have not explicitly studied psilocybin in response to this.
Some researchers have used survey data or animal studies to focus on Ayahuasca/DMT and mescaline, but no comprehensive experimental data for humans has been published to date. This limited research is not included in this briefing but is summarised in another review article focussed on psilocybin and other classical psychedelics.
Regulations vary for each psychedelic compound, and between the various jurisdictions where research is taking place.
In 2017, the FDA granted MDMA ‘breakthrough therapy’ status for the treatment of PTSD and is expected to make a decision regarding possible licensing in the near future. In June 2023, the FDA published guidance for clinical investigations regarding the use of psychedelic drugs. Organisations have placed official requests for MDMA to be licensed in the USA for the treatment of PTSD, and it is approved for use as a PTSD treatment in Australia.
POST is grateful to Dr Stephen Naulls, Clinical Research Fellow at POST, for researching this briefing.
POST would like to thank Basant Pradhan MD, Anthony Rostain MD, and Professor Irving Wainer, Cooper University Hospital, Camden, New Jersey, USA, who acted as external peer reviewers in preparation of this article.
Photo by: (© By Cultura Creative – stock.adobe.com).
Researchers are exploring the science of psychedelic drugs as a potential treatment for depression. How effective could they be, and what are the regulatory and legal challenges in their use?
Researchers are exploring the role of psychedelic drugs as a treatment for eating disorders. How are eating disorders currently treated and what does the latest research on psychedelic drugs show?
This POSTbrief will outline the regulatory and legal landscape for research using psychedelic drugs to treat a wide range of mental health disorders.